Betting on the Future: Top NFL Rookie Prop Bets to Watch in 2025
The excitement of the NFL offseason isn’t just about trades and drafts; it’s also the time when sportsbooks roll out rookie player prop bets. With the 2025 NFL Draft in the rearview, bettors now have their eyes on promising rookies expected to make waves this season.
While wagering months in advance requires patience, early lines offer an edge before the market stabilizes.
Several rookies stand out with intriguing betting lines and realistic paths to exceed expectations. Let’s break down these rookie prop bets and uncover where sharp bettors are focusing.
Cam Ward: A Rookie Quarterback With Opportunity
Cam Ward finds himself at the heart of the Titans’ offense after being drafted first overall. His passing yard prop at FanDuel Sportsbook sits at 3,200.5 yards, with a touchdown prop of 18.5
Ward, fresh off winning the Davey O’Brien Award, displayed remarkable college stats, averaging 331.8 yards per game with a stellar 9.5 YPA. Tennessee’s offense, previously conservative under Brian Callahan, could open up with Ward under center. The Titans’ thin receiving corps beyond Calvin Ridley presents a challenge, but Ward’s projected numbers – 3,460 yards and 20.1 touchdowns, suggest he could comfortably clear his prop totals.
Ashton Jeanty: The Rookie Running Back Favorite
Ashton Jeanty is positioned for a massive workload with the Raiders. His prop lines include 1,050.5 rushing yards and 6.5 touchdowns.
Jeanty dominated college football with 2,601 rushing yards and 29 touchdowns last season, securing the Doak Walker Award. He steps into a favorable situation under Chip Kelly, leading an offense that should lean heavily on his abilities. With minimal backfield competition and Geno Smith at quarterback, Jeanty is projected to eclipse 1,250 yards and 9.5 touchdowns. Bettors are bullish on Jeanty’s role, and he’s already considered the frontrunner for Offensive Rookie of the Year.
Omarion Hampton: Betting on Potential Over Role
Omarion Hampton enters a crowded Chargers backfield but carries a high upside. His prop lines are 800.5 rushing yards and 6.5 touchdowns.
The Chargers’ offseason overhaul included adding Hampton, a dynamic back with elite athleticism. He’ll compete with Najee Harris early on, but many expect Hampton’s talent to shine through. Projected for 970 yards and 8.5 touchdowns, Hampton has the tools to clear both lines. The risk lies in Harris’ potential workload, making this a bet for those confident in Hampton’s rise during the season.
Quinshon Judkins: A Quiet Contender in Cleveland
Quinshon Judkins presents intriguing value among rookie backs. His prop line is set at 625.5 rushing yards.
Judkins immediately assumes a lead role in Cleveland’s backfield, taking over from Nick Chubb.
Despite concerns about the Browns’ offense, Judkins’ workload should be sizable. His blend of speed and power, shown in college with a 5.5 YPC average, positions him well for success. In fact, among the NFL top props and predictions on FanDuel, he stands out, projected for over 900 yards. He looks poised to beat this modest rushing total if the offense remains functional.
Tetairoa McMillan: Touchdown Upside for Carolina’s New Asset
Tetairoa McMillan gives Bryce Young a much-needed target in Carolina. His prop lines stand at 825.5 receiving yards and 4.5 touchdowns.
McMillan dominated at Arizona and could quickly become Carolina’s top receiver. While his yardage prop appears aggressive, his projected six touchdowns make his scoring line enticing. McMillan’s red-zone ability and Young’s improved play hint at him being a reliable scoring threat, making the touchdown over a viable play for bettors.
Embed from Getty ImagesTravis Hunter: A Versatile Star With Uncertain Usage
Travis Hunter offers one of the most unique rookie profiles in recent memory. His prop lines are 725.5 receiving yards and 5.5 touchdowns.
Hunter will primarily play receiver for the Jaguars but could still see defensive snaps. His immense college production shows his potential, yet questions remain about his route volume. Projected for over 900 yards and nearly six touchdowns, Hunter could smash these numbers if given full-time offensive snaps. Still, bettors must weigh the uncertainty of his dual-role usage before committing.
Matthew Golden: Speed Doesn’t Always Translate
Matthew Golden brings blistering speed to Green Bay but faces a tough betting landscape. His receiving yards prop is set at 650.5.
Golden’s 4.29-second 40-yard dash turned heads, yet his collegiate production was modest. The Packers have a crowded receiver room, and Matt LaFleur’s penchant for rotation may limit Golden’s snaps. Projected for 617 yards, expectations lean under on this prop, and bettors may want to fade his yardage line.
Colston Loveland: The Tough Rookie Tight End Market
Colston Loveland faces a challenging path to clear his prop lines of 700.5 receiving yards and 4.5 touchdowns.
Loveland enters a deep Chicago offense and will share time with Cole Kmet. Despite high draft capital, his opportunities could be limited. Projected to fall short of both lines, Loveland’s situation calls for caution among bettors, particularly with Caleb Williams still developing as a passer.
Tyler Warren: A Longshot at Tight End
Tyler Warren is another rookie tight end facing difficult betting odds. His prop sits at 525.5 receiving yards.
Though he won the Mackey Award, Warren lands in a run-heavy Colts offense led by Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones. Despite his talent, the Colts’ passing struggles present a daunting challenge. Projected below his line, Warren may not see the volume required to beat this prop.
Why Ashton Jeanty Leads the OROY Race
Among all rookies, Ashton Jeanty stands out not just for prop bets but also for Offensive Rookie of the Year considerations. His unique blend of vision, contact balance, and role in the offense makes him the favorite. Cam Ward and Tetairoa McMillan are also in the mix, but Jeanty’s workload and situation create a clear edge.
Other rookies like Omarion Hampton and Travis Hunter offer intriguing value, though their paths come with more uncertainty. RJ Harvey and TreVeyon Henderson also carry sleeper potential, especially given their favorable situations.
The Waiting Game Begins
Betting on rookie props in June demands patience but offers long-term value. These early lines present opportunities before adjustments come in training camp and preseason. While not every rookie will deliver, a few already stand out as worthy targets.
The key lies in balancing the upside with role certainty. Bettors willing to act now could find themselves cashing in when the season wraps up. Keep a close eye on player usage reports as the season draws near.
*Content reflects information available as of 07/07/2025; subject to change.
